Try this one and post result
Code:
CMCON=7 ;disable internal comparator
TRISIO=0  ;set pins to outputs

LED1 VAR GPIO.5 ;define GP5 as LED1
LED2 VAR GPIO.4 ;define GP4 as LED2

cont  var byte ;variable for control word of eeprom
value var byte 

cont=$A0 ;control word of eeprom

value=3
I2CWrite GPIO.0,GPIO.1,cont,1,[value]
pause 20
I2CRead GPIO.0,GPIO.1,cont,1,[value]
pause 20
if value=3 then
    LED1=1
    LED2=0
else
    LED2=1
    LED1=0
endif
End
regards