yup 4051 was the one i used too. Few I2C i/o expander were used to control those 4051 lines... well i had 27 of them on-board after all![]()
yup 4051 was the one i used too. Few I2C i/o expander were used to control those 4051 lines... well i had 27 of them on-board after all![]()
Steve
It's not a bug, it's a random feature.
There's no problem, only learning opportunities.
I went the 4051 route before too, but had several problems.
There are 2 different versions. CD4051 and the 74HC4051.
The CD4051, was completely useless. Very high ON resistance (~300 ohms), and very high cross-talk between channels.
The 74HC4051 was better, lower ON resistance (~80 ohms), but the crosstalk was still unacceptable. Readings were still affected by the input from the other channels.
Ended up using a MAX4617 instead. 10 ohm ON resistance and very good crosstalk rejection. (pin compatable with 4051)
A bit more expensive, but it was worth it.
They also have a couple 16 channel multiplexers. Might help with the POT count.
<br>
DT
So i had to be lucky... done since 1 year 1/2, no problem, about 1000 unit sold as now....mmm.
Steve
It's not a bug, it's a random feature.
There's no problem, only learning opportunities.
I suppose it depends on the application. If being 5-10 counts off (10-bit) doesn't matter to your program, then no one will complain.
In mine, it was too much error.
And, only 400 sold (so far).
<br>
Last edited by Darrel Taylor; - 9th July 2006 at 22:25. Reason: .
DT
Yup, you're right. In fact the whole 10bit accuracy wasn't really needed. 8 bit was enough to do the job (motorized fader and pots position). longer ones 100mm /256 steps = 0.4mm or so... not a human will see it.
But i'll keep in mind the one you sugested.
Steve
It's not a bug, it's a random feature.
There's no problem, only learning opportunities.
Thanks to all for the replies.
I found another multiplexer, 74HC(T)4067, 16 to 1 analog. I think it is the one to go (will support 8x16=128 pots maximum!).
Darrel, in your case I suppose that you had AC signals? That's why crosstalk was important. In my case and maybe Steve's DC or low freq does not need any good crosstalk parameter. A HC series might be just fine.
Again thanks to all (and Steve for the files, I got them).
Ioannis
Bookmarks