We'll have to disagree on this one. However I've not killed anybody yet (on the basis it's bad for business) and my designs are used internationally - many with UL certification, so either I'm lucky or I must be doing something right. *smiles*
We'll have to disagree on this one. However I've not killed anybody yet (on the basis it's bad for business) and my designs are used internationally - many with UL certification, so either I'm lucky or I must be doing something right. *smiles*
Hi,
Ground Fault Circuit Interrupters (GFCI)
A GFCI will trip under a shorted Neutral-Ground condition even
if no load is connected to the circuit -- that is, no load
other than the short between neutral and ground.
Here in Italy the GFCI will trip because of this fuse between
neutral and ground. (See figure 3 and 4 Microchip TB008).
Best regards,
Luciano
The circuit shown is probably not intended to be plugged into a CFGI nor into any power grid other than in North America.
Here, ground and neutral are not necessarily at the same potential. Recent changes in the National Electric Code call for the ground lead to connect to the center-tap of the utility transformer and for neutral to connect to earth ground at the entrance panel.
I haven't said that fuse should be used in the UK or Europe nor have I, in any way, been critical of Melanie's design skills.
The fuse will like that!Originally Posted by dhouston
Best regards,
Luciano
Actually Dave you quoted me as "both inaccurate and dangerous".
I challenge that.
I don't care what part of the world you're in, the Fuse in Figure 3 of TB008 is a complete waste of time, offering NO protection - let's repeat that in case anyone missed it first time around - offering NO protection to the User of that circuit. If that Fuse is in or out, the circuit will be LIVE. Microchip have dropped a bollock on this one - so let's direct the "inaccurate and dangerous" where it's needed - the author of TB008.
Hi All,
There seems to be a great deal of confusion among hobbyists and new professionals concerning ground and circuit ground.
I stopped calling the “common” connections in electrical / electronic circuits, “ground”, 30 years ago. Most of us, have worked out the dual meaning of ground. On one hand we actually mean earth ground, next we simply mean a common connection in our circuit.
This dual meaning is okay most of the time, but sometimes it causes misunderstandings and even dangerous situations. Transformerless power supplies are a common battle ground for the semantics of the term, “ground”. This is because, the misunderstandings lead to safety problems. Problems that cannot be ignored.
Melanie, as usual is the voice of reason and spot on. The TB008 application note, is right out of the twilight zone. The author, obviously has some confusion about “ground” and “common”.
I post this diagram to help illustrate what Melanie already pointed out.
Ohm it's not just a good idea... it's the LAW !
Nice to see the modified diagram but U have missed a vital component.Originally Posted by Pic_User
There should be small resistor like 22 Ohm( Ur LAW) to 47 ohm in serries
with 1uf/250V capacitor ( Melani wont approve of this ).Otherwise in few
days that capacitor will be reduced to open circuit (if of metallised film
type) or get short (if Film foil type) and whole ckt will go up in smoke.
The resistors should be atleast 1/2 watt type ( 1watt better). A high value
resistor like 220K is better placed across capacitor to protect user if he
accidently touches capacitor even when ckt is disconnected from mains.
Originally Posted by Melanie
In this case, the circuit will protect itself but kill the user !
--------------------------
"If the Earth were a single state, Istanbul would be its capital." Napoleon Bonaparte
Bookmarks