Man, there's so many choices out there. I have tried AutotraxEDA (which will soon be available on OSX apparently) on windows, and it sucked. Certain things caused it to crash completely without responding, and sometimes it would take a minute or two to startup, even though it apparently wasn't actually doing anything. AFAIK it's being developed by only one guy... he has a lot of faith in it, but it seems pretty terrible to me.
Eagle seems pretty wierd to me too - the only reason I wanted to learn it was because it runs on OSX.
Bookmarks