I got this to work but I had to put it on the MSSP port at 100Khz and separate it from the software controlled I2C control.

I tried putting everything on the MSSP port and switching speeds on the fly to talk to different I2C devices but things went a little hay wire. My comminucation with the AR1020 went crazy when I did this. I probably had something wrong and didn't see it. It was late.