Well it was just a question. Thanks to Melanie an Ralph for your honesty on that.

I think we will leave it like this. Posting a link to thread it's an idea i do sometimes too.

By the way, and i know it was already post before, the thread title should give a good idea of what the thread is about. I mean "newbie need help" "help with code" mean absolutely nothing and it's not a good reference for anyone if they're looking for something more specific.

I would expect at least a "thanks, that has solved my problem"
or any other feedback would be nice.
i agree with this Ralph.