RA.4 Open collector,...

[tazntex]

First thing, yes I did search the forum on this question although I was certain I already was correct in my thoughts about ra.4 on my 16F628A. Melanie makes it quite clear especially with this post:
http://www.picbasic.co.uk/forum/showthread.php?t=1642

BUT!!!, Using and led with a resistor on my anode going to 3.3V and my cathode to ra.4, does not work, change processors and programmed with my replacement of the pickit3, my new favorite, the pickit2. I think I even made it as simple as possible with this code:

DEFINE OSC 4
CMCON = %00100101
VRCON = %11101100
PAUSEus 10
TRISA = %00000110
TRISB = %11110001
PORTA = %00000000
PORTB = %00000000
OPTION_REG.7 = 0
OPTION_REG.6 = 0
rf var porta.4


main:
low rf
pause 500
high rf
pause 500
goto main

And it still doesn't work. But I did move the cathode to ground and yes the led lit, so the led does work.

Anyhow, this may have sounded like a stupid question but If I don't ask, I'll never learn anything
Thanks again especially for all the knowledge I have gained here on this forum.

[tazntex]

I have it working with this code:
DEFINE OSC 4
CMCON=%00000111
VRCON = 0
PAUSEus 10
TRISA = %00000110
TRISB = %11110001
PORTA = %00000000
PORTB = %00000000
OPTION_REG.7 = 0
OPTION_REG.6 = 0
rf var porta.4

main:
low rf
pause 500
high rf
pause 500
goto main

Does it have something to do with me using the comparator on ra.1,ra.2? I have been reading the datasheet and it mentions ra.3,ra.4 in section5.1 PORTA and TRISA Registers, I am already using ra.3 with no problems as an output.

[gadelhas]

Hi;

Try this;

1 - Connect the RA4 Pin with the resistor to VCC;
2 - Connect the anode of the led beetwen the resistor and the RA4 Pin;
3 - Connect the Cathode of the led to GND

And post the result

[rsocor01]

The reason that you need a resistor between RA4 and Vcc, like Gadelhas mentioned above, is because RA4 in that chip is an Open Drain (OD) type.



Robert

[tazntex]

Sorry about the delay getting back to ya'll. Ok, your instructions said:
1 - Connect the RA4 Pin with the resistor to VCC;
2 - Connect the anode of the led beetwen the resistor and the RA4 Pin;
3 - Connect the Cathode of the led to GND

with or without step 2 the led is illuminated.

Thanks for the fast response.

[Bruce]

RA4 is C2OUT with the 1st configuration you had so you couldn't use it for a digital output. With comparators disabled you can.

This should work fine to drive your LED on RA4 ---|<|---/\/\/--VCC.

[tazntex]

Bruce, thats how I have it, However, I have brown out reset enable on my winpic programmer software, tried it with PICkit3, PICkit2 and it won't work, BUT if I turn off the brown out reset manually in WINPIC programmer, It WORKS
But I am going from 9v input to my breadboard, then LP2950ACZ-3.3 (3.3V) regulator to my processor, sure would be nice to use the low voltage (brown out).

Any ideas?

Thanks

[Bruce]

If turning an LED on is tripping reset you might want a larger cap on the reg output or larger series resistor for the LED. BOR definitely shouldn't trip unless you're dropping a lot of power.

Edit: Check the datasheet for Vbor. You may already be running marginal.

[tazntex]

I'll do that this evening, Thanks to everyone for your help.

[tazntex]

I did read about the Vbor, but also in the electrical specifications, it state minimum brown out reset voltage is 3.65V. Using a 3.3V regulator I rekon that cuts that out of the picture.

Well, I don't mean to get off of my original thread but since I am here and ya'll are reading this...
When using Darryl Taylors Interrup's and MPASM how does one set the config bits,thats where I can turn it off, I have been using this PBP compiler with sucess :
@ DEVICE PIC16F628a,XT_OSC
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, WDT_OFF
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, PWRT_ON
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, MCLR_ON
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, BOD_OFF
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, LVP_OFF
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, CPD_OFF
@ DEVICE pic16F628a, PROTECT_OFF
I have even opened the 16F628A.INC in the PBP directory and it is turned off with the above added to my code when I compile using MPASM it won't compile, I get a bunch of errors. If I delete the above it compiles fine.
Meanwhile, I am reading Melanie's post again to see what I've missed: http://www.picbasic.co.uk/forum/cont...o-your-Program
Thank you

[gadelhas]

Hi;

You must do it like this;

@ __config _INTRC_OSC_NOCLKOUT & _WDT_OFF & _MCLRE_OFF & _LVP_OFF & _CP_OFF &_PWRTE_OFF

See this post;

http://www.picbasic.co.uk/forum/show...hlight=16f628a

[tazntex]

Thanks Gadelhas for the fast reply, I tried to compile using that and I get this error:


@ __CONFIG _XT_OSC & _WDT_OFF & _MCLRE_ON & _LVP_OFF & _CP_OFF
DEFINE OSC 4
CMCON=%00000111
VRCON = 0
PAUSEus 10
TRISA = %00000110
TRISB = %11110001
PORTA = %00000000
PORTB = %00000000
OPTION_REG.7 = 0
OPTION_REG.6 = 0
rf var porta.4

main:
low rf
pause 500
high rf
pause 500
goto main
Error[118]c:\program~1\testled.asm 83 : overwriting previous address contents (2007)

What does this mean?

Many Thanks

[tazntex]

Perhaps I could use the external brown out protection with the 3.3V regulator as shown on the datasheet, I like the Example2 version.

[gadelhas]

Hi;

To not give that error you need to go to the file of your pic model in the PBP directory and comment that line, like this;

;*  16F628A.INC                                                 *
;*                                                              *
;*  By        : Leonard Zerman, Jeff Schmoyer                   *
;*  Notice    : Copyright (c) 2003 microEngineering Labs, Inc.  *
;*              All Rights Reserved                             *
;*  Date      : 11/06/03                                        *
;*  Version   : 2.45                                            *
;*  Notes     :                                                 *
;****************************************************************
        NOLIST
    ifdef PM_USED
        LIST
        include 'M16F62xA.INC'  ; PM header
        device  pic16F628A, xt_osc, wdt_on, mclr_on, lvp_off, protect_off
        XALL
        NOLIST
    else
        LIST
        LIST p = 16F628A, r = dec, w = -302
        INCLUDE "P16F628A.INC"  ; MPASM  Header
        ;__config _XT_OSC & _WDT_ON & _MCLRE_ON & _LVP_OFF & _CP_OFF '- COMENT THIS LINE WITH ";" ATE THE BEGINNING
        NOLIST
    endif
        LIST

[tazntex]

I did see that but just thought that was to easy and I must have been missing something. But I have done what you said and it works.

Thank you very much for your help