PDA

View Full Version : Crystal vs Resonator



DynamoBen
- 17th August 2006, 20:48
I'm constructing a circuit for outdoor use. I was thinking about using a resonator to save space vs. a crystal/capacitor combo.

Any advantages or disadvantages I need to consider?

Acetronics2
- 17th August 2006, 21:07
Hi Dynamo,

If there are no critical time issues ... no problem. just have a look at tempco and freq. precision to see what.

Alain

DynamoBen
- 17th August 2006, 21:15
I'm doing serial @9600, I2C, and OWIN/OWOUT.

Melanie
- 17th August 2006, 21:20
A resonator is good for the above and should save you a couple of capacitors if you select one with internal caps.

DynamoBen
- 17th August 2006, 21:22
I had two thoughts while laying out the board, save on space AND I believe a resonator is better when there are going to be temperature extremes. Correct?

JIM A
- 23rd October 2006, 04:04
Crystals Are Better For Initial Calibration Accuracy And Temperature Stability.

Resonators Are Typically 0.3% Accurate And 0.1% Temperature Stability, While Crystals Are 0.005% On Both Accounts. In Most Applications, The Resonator Is Adequate However.

I Have One Project That Has Timers Running Up To 24 Hour Range And Temperature Exposure Of 0-90 Degrees Farenheit And Used A Crystal For Stability.

Most Projects I Design Are Ok With The Internal Rc Clock.